There are baseball general managers who build dynasties. There are GMs who develop young talent, who draft brilliantly, who construct championship contenders year after year through patience and vision. And then, in a category entirely his own, there is Kenny Williams, the man who somehow turned U.S. Cellular Field into a live-action Beckett Baseball Card Price Guide.
Kenny, this one's for you. Pull up a rocking chair. You've earned it.
For a certain generation of White Sox fans...those of us who spent childhood summers hunched over three-ring binders stuffed with plastic card sleeves, carefully organizing our collections by team, position, and "mint condition" status, the Williams era defied conventional sports logic. Sure, the team wasn't always easy to watch. Sure, there were seasons where checking the standings felt like peeking at a medical diagnosis you already suspected was bad. But at least when you walked into Comiskey (sorry, U.S. Cellular, sorry, Guaranteed Rate), there was a decent chance you'd look up from your hot dog and see someone you had a rookie card for.
"Kenny Williams didn't just sign aging superstars. He curated an experience. He was a GM, a curator, and a baseball card shop owner all rolled into one."
The Art of the Sentimental Signing
Let's be honest about what was happening here. Ken Williams had a gift...a truly rare and special gift...for identifying players who were 70% done being great and saying, yes, that's our guy. Not because the on-field results were necessarily going to be spectacular. But because there was something deeply human, deeply Chicago, about giving a legend one more curtain call. Even if the curtain was a little frayed. Even if the lighting wasn't great. Even if the crowd wasn't entirely sure what they were applauding for.
And here's the thing...it worked. Not always in the win column. But in that ineffable quality that makes baseball more than a sport. The nostalgia. The "wait, is that who I think it is?" moment. The nine-year-old in you suddenly snaps to attention because Ken Griffey Jr. just trotted out to center field, and you once had his Upper Deck rookie card tucked between your mattress and box spring for "safekeeping."
The Players Who Made Us Feel Like Kids Again
Before I begin the list, I should say that not all of these players were signed by Kenny Williams...just the ones I remember the most. It does show some consistency in our franchise to reach into discount bin and occasionally finding a treasure.
Ken Griffey Jr. arrived on the South Side in 2008, acquired at the trade deadline from Cincinnati, and brought with him 608 career home runs, the most photogenic swing in baseball history, and approximately 40 million childhood memories. He hit three home runs for the Sox and, more importantly, made one of the greatest throws in franchise history...gunning down Michael Cuddyer at home plate in the legendary "Blackout Game" that clinched the AL Central. He played 41 games. Was it enough Griffey? No. Was it some Griffey? Absolutely, unambiguously yes.
Manny Ramirez, he of the dreadlocks and the almost supernatural ability to hit a baseball to any part of the planet, appeared in a White Sox uniform in 2010 for 24 games. He hit exactly one home run as a member of the Sox. One. Out of 546 career home runs. And yet, there he was, Manny being Manny on our team, which felt like finding a Honus Wagner card in a shoebox in your grandmother's attic.
Roberto Alomar, a 12-time All-Star and Hall of Fame second baseman with one of the silkiest defensive gloves in the game's history, graced the Sox with his presence in 2003 and 2004. Roberto Alomar! The same Roberto Alomar who was one of the best all-around players of the 1990s! Playing second base on the South Side! The stats were not what they once were, naturally - he was in his mid 30s, and time is an undefeated opponent - but the name on the back of the jersey gave parents everywhere the chance to lean over to their children and say, "You know, that guy used to be absolutely unbelievable."
Sandy Alomar Jr. came along as well, because apparently Kenny Williams looked at the situation and thought, "Why have one Alomar when you can have two?" Sandy, a six-time All-Star catcher and 1990 Rookie of the Year, signed on as a veteran backstop and gave the team the kind of seasoned leadership that only a man who has caught for most of the American League can provide.
Jose Canseco...the Bash Brother, the A's MVP, the man who wrote a book that shook the foundations of the sport, finished his career with the White Sox in 2001, stepping in as DH after Frank Thomas went down with an injury. He clubbed 16 home runs in 76 games at age 36, posted a .843 OPS, and gave every Sox fan of a certain age the chance to root for a man whose baseball card they had treated with the kind of reverence usually reserved for religious artifacts.
Jim Thome, the gentle giant slugger who hit 612 career home runs with a swing like a lumberjack felling a redwood, joined the Sox in 2006 with 430 home runs already in his pocket. He was still dangerous. He was still Jim Thome. And getting to watch him pull baseballs into the upper deck at The Cell felt like a gift.
Kevin Youkilis, "The Greek God of Walks," arrived on the South Side in the summer of 2012 via trade from the Red Sox...which, for a certain generation of baseball fans, felt roughly equivalent to receiving a gift from a rival. Youkilis had been one of the best players in baseball from 2008 to 2010, a three-time All-Star, Gold Glove first baseman, and the patron saint of on-base percentage. By the time he arrived in Chicago, injuries had worn him down considerably, and the numbers were nowhere near what Sox fans had watched torture them from the other dugout for years. But there he was..."Youk," the scowling, bat-waggling, crouch-stance embodiment of gritty baseball...wearing black and white. His White Sox manager Robin Ventura called him a competitor with a "grinder mentality" who fit right in with his teammates. For one strange, nostalgic summer, the Greek God of Walks was ours.
John Kruk, the beloved, shaggy, proudly unathletic three-time All-Star who once told a woman criticizing his lifestyle, "I ain't an athlete, lady. I'm a baseball player." signed with the Sox in 1995 as a designated hitter, his body having largely staged a mutiny after years of hard living and harder baseball. He batted .308 in his only season with the club, which was a perfectly respectable Kruk line. Then on July 30, he singled against the Orioles, advanced to first base, and simply... walked off the field and retired, right there, on the spot, due to chronic knee soreness. No press conference. No farewell tour. Just a man on first base deciding he was done, and being completely correct about it. It was the most John Kruk ending imaginable, and somehow it happened in a White Sox uniform.
Julio Franco, a man who somehow appeared to be in his mid-30s for approximately 25 consecutive years, also did a stint on the South Side, adding to a career so long it seems to have begun during the Fillmore administration. Franco played until he was 49 years old. The White Sox were just one stop on his epic, inexplicable, wonderful journey through time.
Tony Phillips, the ultimate super-utility player who played every position except pitcher and catcher with equal parts skill and chaos, brought his particular brand of scrappy, lunch-pail baseball to Chicago and fit right in with a South Side ethos that has always valued hustle over glamour.
Tim Raines, the "Rock," the Hall of Fame outfielder from Montreal who could get on base with the frequency of a commuter train, had stints with the Sox that let a new generation appreciate one of the most underrated leadoff hitters of all time.
And let us not forget the pitchers. Tom Seaver, "Tom Terrific" himself, one of the greatest right-handers in the history of the game, ended up wearing a Sox uniform from 1984 to 1986 after the Mets left him exposed in a free-agent compensation draft. The White Sox claimed him, perhaps the most accidental masterstroke in the franchise's history. Then Steve Carlton, Lefty himself, four-time Cy Young winner, followed in 1986, still throwing, still competing, a little like watching your favorite band on their fifth farewell tour...you knew it wasn't peak-era Carlton, but just being in the room felt special.
* All players listed appeared in a White Sox uniform. Some stats may have been better in your memory than in the box score. That is okay. That is baseball.
A Letter to My Baseball Card Collection
Here is something I never expected as a kid, carefully peeling open wax packs and comparing stats on the backs of cards...that one day, those players would show up on my team. Not in their prime, not as the players depicted on the cards - hair perfectly airbrushed, uniform pristine, stats still accumulating - but as real human beings in the winter of their careers, playing for a sometimes-mediocre team on the South Side of Chicago.
And you know what? It was better than any card.
You could argue the baseball was better when Griffey was hitting 56 homers in Seattle, or when Manny was terrorizing the American League in Cleveland and Boston, or when Roberto Alomar was making impossible plays in Cleveland, Toronto and Baltimore look effortless. You'd be right. But watching those same players wear our black and white? That was something cards could never give you. That was time, folded back on itself. That was the strange, generous magic of a GM who apparently had a soft spot for legends...and maybe, just maybe, for the kids who collected their cards.
The Proper Thank You
So, Kenny...Thank you! Thank you for understanding that baseball is not purely about wins and losses, though wins and losses obviously matter quite a lot. Thank you for understanding that for a certain kind of fan...the kind who still remembers what their card collection smelled like, who still knows the career batting average of players who retired before they were in high school...seeing those names on a Sox jersey meant something that transcended the standings.
Thank you for Jose Canseco's last hurrah. For Jim Thome's majestic home runs echoing off The Cell's upper deck. For Julio Franco's immortal refusal to age. For 24 magical games of Manny being Manny in our colors. For Ken Griffey Jr.'s throw, THAT throw, that will live forever in White Sox history.
The team wasn't always easy to watch. But it was always, reliably, worth looking up from your hot dog for. Because you never quite knew who might be standing out there, some legend from a dog-eared card in a binder you still have somewhere in a closet, looking a little older, a little slower, but still, unmistakably, themselves.
That's not nothing. In fact, for a certain kind of fan, that's everything.
Comments
Post a Comment